Why Investing In Yearly Rental Homes Long Term vs Short Term Has Its Advantages

Joseph Jennings | Broker, ABR, PPM, CAM
Tag: Investing in Rental Homes
why-investing-in-yearly-rental-homes-long-term-vs-short-term-has-its-advantages

Published: Feb. 14, 2023

Why investing in Yearly Rental homes (Long Term) vs Short Term Rental (STR) has its advantages.

Owning a short-term rental can be a tempting idea, but you may find the reality of being responsible for one difficult to take on. A short-term rental (STR) is typically offered as an alternative to a hotel, and they’re an investment that’s gained popularity in recent years. According to a Harris Poll survey, 28% of homeowners have considered using a rental service to temporarily rent out their home for additional income. As a real estate investor, the ultimate goal is to maximize returns on investment while minimizing risk. 

Owning a rental property that rents out on a yearly basis versus a short-term rental property offers several benefits that make it the better option for many investors.

  1. Stability of income One of the most significant advantages of owning a yearly rental property is the stability of income. With a yearly rental, the landlord has a guaranteed source of income for the entire year, allowing for more predictable cash flow and easier budgeting. On the other hand, short-term rentals are subject to fluctuations in demand and can experience periods of low occupancy, resulting in a less consistent source of income.
  2. Lower maintenance costs Short-term rentals tend to have higher maintenance costs due to the constant wear and tear caused by frequent turnover of tenants. Short term tenants tend to cause more wear and tear because they are only there for a very short term and can care less about the home. On the other hand, yearly rentals typically have fewer maintenance issues as tenants are more likely to treat the property with care and respect. This results in lower maintenance costs and fewer headaches for the landlord.
  3. Lower turnover costs Turnover costs, such as cleaning and advertising expenses, can add up quickly with short-term rentals. These costs can be substantial and eat into the landlord’s profits. With yearly rentals, the turnover costs are significantly lower, as the tenant stays for an extended period, and the landlord only needs to find a new tenant every 12 months.
  4. Greater tenant satisfaction and dealing with less complaints from short term tenants thinking your property is the same as a hotel. Yearly rental tenants tend to be more satisfied with their living arrangements as they have a sense of stability and security in their living situation. They are also more likely to treat the property with respect, leading to a lower likelihood of damage and fewer maintenance issues. In contrast, short-term tenants may not have the same level of investment in the property, leading to less care and more frequent damage.

In Conclusion

In conclusion, owning a rental property that rents on a yearly basis provides real estate investors with several benefits, including a more stable income, lower maintenance costs, lower turnover costs, and greater tenant satisfaction. While short-term rentals may offer higher returns in the short term, the benefits of a yearly rental make it the better option for many real estate investors in the long run.

For more information about unique real estate investments reach out to Joe Jennings, Broker Sunny and Associates Real Estate of Florida

Joe Jennings Broker for Sunny & Associates Realty

What Is Next For The Housing Market, Is It The Right Time To Buy, Sell Or Rent?

In today’s news what we are hearing about the housing market can leave you with more questions than answers. Is the market losing momentum…

Tallahassee, The Capital City Of Florida, An Attractive Location For Real Estate Investors

Tallahassee, the capital city of Florida, offers a compelling opportunity for real estate investment. With a combination of steady demand…

New Cash Offer Program for Sellers

Looking to sell your home quickly and hassle-free? Sunny & Associates Realty has an exciting new option for you – our Cash Offer Program.

Multigenerational Homes in Tallahassee: Shared Living Solutions for Extended Families

Multigenerational homes—properties with private suites, extra living areas, or room to add an independent unit—help families share costs, support each other, and adapt over time.

Relocating or Moving to South Florida? Here’s a few Pros, Cons & Home Search Tips

Like all places, South Florida has its pros and its cons. With the number of people moving to South Florida each day it is obvious the Cons..

Tallahassee Real Estate Market Spotlight: Why Buyers Are Focusing on Golden Eagle Country Club

As a premier destination for homes for sale in Tallahassee, Golden Eagle is one of the region’s most prestigious gated golf communities. Known for its championship course and controlled development, it offers a lifestyle that newer subdivisions struggle to replicate.

Factors That Affect The Price Of The Home, What Sellers Should Know

Selling a house is a big decision and it’s important to know what it is worth. Not in your eyes, but what the buyers are willing to pay.

Golden Eagle Country Club Homes for Sale in Tallahassee: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know in 2026

If you’re searching for Golden Eagle Country Club homes for sale or thinking about selling a home in Golden Eagle, you’re looking at one of the most established and consistently performing communities in the Tallahassee real estate market.

Understanding Leon County Property Taxes — Your Complete Guide to Buying and Selling Real Estate in the Tallahassee Metro Area

Buying or selling a home in the Tallahassee metro area isn’t just about market timing — it’s also about understanding how Leon County property taxes affect your home’s value, affordability, and buyer appeal.

Homes for Sale on Lake Talquin – Explore Florida’s Hidden Waterfront Gem

Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway, an investment property, or a forever home, the Lake Talquin real estate market offers exceptional value compared to other Florida lakefront communities.

sunny-associates-best-rated-realtor-broker-plantation-fl-joe-jennings-1-b

Top Rated Real Estate Broker

Real Estate Markets:
Tallahassee, Treasure Coast, Jensen Beach, Stuart, Port St. Lucie and Vero Beach Florida.